• Home
  • Dharma talk with Nomon Tim Burnett - Shantideva: Calling for Help

Dharma talk with Nomon Tim Burnett - Shantideva: Calling for Help

  • Friday, November 13, 2026
  • 7:00 PM - 7:30 PM
  • Bozeman Dharma Center

Stream audio:



Stream video:

Talk Notes:

Here's the story that's told about our man Shantideva as a monk at the great monastic university of Nalanda in northern India:

This is the traditional Tibetan account, from Butön (fourteenth century) and Tāranātha (seventeenth). It’s hagiography, with no contemporary Indian source.

The setup. Śāntideva was a prince in the west of India, the son of King Mañjuśrīvarman (variants of the name exist). Mañjuśrī appeared to him before his coronation, and he fled the throne for the path. He took ordination at Nālandā under the abbot Jayadeva and was given the name Śāntideva.

The nickname. At Nālandā he seemed to do nothing. The monks gave him the name Bhusuku, from three syllables standing for eating (bhuñjati), sleeping (supta), and going to the latrine (kuṭi). He was supposedly the one monk who performed no study, recitation, or meditation, only those three activities. In fact he was composing the Śikṣāsamuccaya Training Anthology in his cell, and he was meditating by night.

The recitation. His fellow monks decided to humiliate him and get him expelled. They built a very high throne and invited him to deliver a teaching, assuming he couldn’t climb it, or at least couldn’t fill it. He ascended it anyway, and in some tellings the throne rose or he simply sat in it unaided. He asked whether they wanted something already heard or something new. They asked for something new, and he began reciting the Bodhicaryāvatāra.

The climax. When he reached the verse in chapter 9 on wisdom on non-apprehension, where neither existence nor non-existence stands before the mind, he rose into the sky. He disappeared but his voice continued, and the monks heard the rest of the recitation from the air.

Aftermath. The monks traced him and asked him to come back. He declined and travelled on.

It is curious to me that Shantideva's wonderful teachings from the 8th century weren't popular in China, and thus were largely unknown in Japan. It's probably because core Buddhist text like the Lakavatara Sutra, Platform Sutra, the wonderful Vimalakirti sutra, and others were already well established in China in the 5th century. Buddhism went to Tibet later - 7th century or so - and the Tibetan masters also just focussed more on contemporary Indian teachings than the Chinese did.

The first chapter of the Bodhicaryāvatāra - the Guide to being a Bodhisattva, we were looking at yesterday was called Praise for the Awakening Mind - and remember that is translating bodhicitta - the flash of insight of awakening.

Perhaps surprisingly the second chapter is called Confession of Faults. And right away we might constrict a little - perhaps especially those with a Catholic background - but let's take a look. I think we might see these teachings as something like "Don't Hide Anything" or "Be Real". That holding shameful secrets is a barrier to practice.

And also that if we unpack the mental impulses behind poor behavior in ourselves, or others, and the impulse to obscure or avoid being totally open and honest we see that there are some deep misunderstandings there around what we do and why. That confessing, feeling remorse, and being open and vulnerable doesn't just lighten our load it helps us see and understand the true Dharma. The way things really are.

There's another core teaching of Buddhism at play here which can be a difficult one for us to make sense of. And that is that although we've all heard lots of teachings around acceptance and that everything's fine just the way it is, there's also an important role to play for not settling for the ultimately never quite satisfying life of trying to get our deepest needs met in the realm of everyday life. That the ways we try to optimize and improve our lives are never going to quite do it. Even the better job has problems. Even the better suited life partner is challenging to live with. Even the best fill-in-the-blank isn't quite exactly what we wanted. Do you know what I'm talking about? The analysis of Buddhism is that it isn't just that we live in an unfair Capitalist system and all that stuff but that very nature of the world of stuff and personalities - of desire and aversion - is inherently never gonna quite do it.

So there are teachings here around how it's actually essential not to get too comfortable in the relative world. To see the danger of falling into trying to attain ultimate satisfaction from a sphere of existence that is never gonna deliver. And the emotion that Shantideva's going to suggest to us around the tempations of that is fear actually. We should be a bit terrified by how seductive all of that is.

And to look at just one extreme example of this we've lately had all over the news the tales of world's richest man. I don't know about you but my read of Elon Musk is that he's miserable. Very smart maybe. Always trying stuff. Pushing himself hard. But why would you need to be that racist and mysoginest and actually have become the world's greediest man if you were content. Turns out billions and billions of dollars don't make you happy. So that's the danger. Don't be an Elon even a baby Elon. And the analysis is that we need to own up to the ways that we already are.

The great blues guitarist Keb Mo' put it this way:

image.png

Keb Mo' Victims of Comfort

No rocket's gonna fly that high
There's no escaping the enemy he's you and I
We poison up our water, we're chokin' on the air
Last stop before it gets too late or is it already too late?

Is it already too late
For the victims of comfort?
Got no one else to blame
We're just the victims of comfort

We cannot soothe the pain
And it's a technological merry-go-round
Dangerous solutions buried under the ground
And everyone likes a party

But no-one wants to clean
Well I'd like to see a change somehow and I believe we're busy right now
Just a little busy right now
I am just a victim of comfort

I got no one else to blame
I'm just a victim of comfort
Cryin' shame

So here at last are a few verses from Shantideva. Like many traditional teachings the language is enthusiastic, emphatic, even extreme sometimes to our ears so we listen for the intent for how we can practice with these teachings.

2.28 Throughout the beginningless cycle of existence, and again in this very birth, the evil I, a brute, have done or caused,

2.29 Or anything I, deluded, have rejoiced in to my own detriment, I confess those transgressions and am tormented by remorse.

2.30 The harm I have done, in arrogance, to the Three Jewels, or to my mothers and fathers, or to others worthy of respect, with my body, speech, and mind;

2.31 The cruel evil I have wickedly done, corupted by many faults, O Teachers, I confess it all.

2.35 I did evil in many ways on account of friends and enemies. This I did not understand: I must abandon all and let go.

2.36 Those I loathe will die; those I love will die; I too will die; and all will die.

2.37 Everything experienced fades into memory. Everything is like an image in a dream. It is gone and is not seen again.

2.43 By clinging to this transient life, not recognizing the danger, headless, O Buddhas, I have acquired great evil.

[Then a bunch of verses on how if we really feel the truth of things we should be horrified by our imperfect behavior, for buying into the victims of comfort club, we should really feel bad about it and recognize the severity of the negative karmic consquences of trying to make ourselves feel desire, comfort, distraction, avoidance and greedy actions]

And then he humbly calls for help from the bodhisattvas. When you really realize how sucked under and seduced we've been by the false promises of trying to fix our illusory self in a conditioned world, he feels, it's appropriate to be horrified.

Where he uses the language of fear but we can maybe think of that like that, "What on earth am I doing?!" kind of energy. Putting our efforts and energy in all the wrong places.

2.50 Trembling with fear I give myself to Samantabhadra, and again freely I give myself to Manjushri.

2.51 Terrified I cry out in anguish to the Protector Avalaokiteshvara whose conduct overflows with compassion. I have made mistakes. May she protect me.

2.52 Seeking deliverance with all my heart I cry out to noble Jizo all of those of great compassion.

It's hard for most of us, I think, to ask for help. It's hard to ask for help from tangible people in our lives and it's hard to ask for help from the less tangible bodhisattvas, Buddha, spirits and Gods all around us.

I grew up skeptical of calling for help from gods and such things so it's odd to me to have ended up a Buddhist priest. One of the things I most appreciate is the support to live into devotion in the rituals I get to be in the middle of. When I bow to Avalokitesvara on your altar here I do my best to really let her see me. It's a practice that's gradually working it's way into my heart.

That kind of calling for help came up in a way last night. I was super, super tired for most of the evening but I kept frittering and not turning out the light. And then when I finally did I was restless and couldn't settle! I started into that unhelpful cycle of telling myself how late it was getting and how tired I would be tomorrow - we know how much that helps!

Then, I an image came into my head of myself teaching and lying there grouchy in bed I could listen to my wiser self telling all of us: be gentle, let go, do your practice. It was like I was in the zendo here listening to myself. So I went to the Thich Nhat Hanh gatha and it really helped.

Calming body and mind / Smiling with joy / Living in the present moment / Knowing it's the only moment.

It's hard to describe how this wasn't just remembering that I have all of these tools, but more like calling out for help in my frustration and receiving an answer. Maybe it was actually Avalokitesvara who was answering in the guide of me-as-teacher. Do you know what I mean?

Shantideva closes the chapter called "Confession of Faults" like this:

2.64 Whatever foolishness, I a deluded fool, have amassed, what is wrong by nature and what is wrong by convention,

2.65 I confess all of that as I stand before the Protectors, my palms together in reverence, terrified of suffering, prostrating myself again and again.

2.66 Let the Leaders accept my transgression and confusion for what it is. It is not good, O Protectors. I must not do it again.

Hopefully you have a little stamina left so we can touch into the third chapter. Here after taking care of thorougly releasing our negative sticky tendencies - choosing to no longer be just a victim of comfort - there's room for tremendous joy at the possibilities of a life lives in Buddha's house instead of the houses of desire, aversion, and endless wandering in seek of satisfaction in all of the wrong places. What a relief! I think the process of practice he's offering here is that we need to be able to endure going into the dark places of our hearts and really looking around, but don't get stuck there, then open out again to the light of Buddha's love and wisdom.

3.1 I rejoice with delight at all the good done by all beings, which abates the sufferings of hell. May those who are suffering abide once again in happiness!

3.2 I rejoice at the deliverance of embodies beings from the suffering of cyclic existence. I rejoice with the Bodhisattvas and Buddhas.

3.3 I also rejoice at the resolutions of the teachers, which are oceans bearing happiness to every being, bestowing well being on all creatures.

3.4 Holding my hands together in reverence, I beseech the perfect Buddhas in all directions, "Set up the light of the Dharma for those falling into suffering in the darkness of delusion."

3.5 Holding my hads together in reverence, I implore the awakened ones who may wish to leave cyclic existnce, "Please remain for endless aeons. Do not let this world become blind!"

3.6 With all of the good acquired by doing all this as described, may I allay all the suffering of every living being.

3.7 I am medicine for the sick. May I be botht he doctor and their nurse, until sickness does not recur.

3.8 May I avert the pain of hunger and thrist with showers of food and drink - even in times of famine.

3.9 May I be an inexhaustible treasure for impoverished beings. May I wait upon them with many forms of offering.

3.18 May I be a light for those in need of a light. May I be a bed for those in need of rest. May I be a servant for those in need of service - for all embodied beings.

3.19 May I be the wish-fulfilling jewel, the pot of plenty, the spell that always works, the potent healing herb, the magical free that grants every wish, and the milk-cow that supplies all wants.

3.21 May I be sustenance of every kind for the realm of all beings throughout space, until all have attained release.

So that's the beautiful spirit of our practice. In Zen we tend to keep a little quiet and we don't wander around reciting this devotional poetry to suffering beings but the invitation is to cultivate this spirit in our hearts. Bodhicitta isn't a project or a chore. It's an opportunity into joyful and delightful service for all beings.

It's not easy we also need to plumb the depths of our suffering. We need to develop our wisdom. We need to understand and abandon all kinds of negative patterns - and ultimately to see through them as being just illusions - not so real or compelling and controlling as they at first appear. We also need to be vulnerable and honest. And we need to notice when we're getting stuck on comfort and renew our commitment to practice regularly and deeply. So this is not nothing but it's not a chore or a burden. Perhaps there are periods where it feels like it is and we'll need to practice wisely, call on our Dharma friends, ask for help from the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas until we get through the sticky bits, but It's ultimately it's the most wondrous joys. 




www.RedCedarZen.org     360-389-3444     registrar@redcedarzen.org
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software