Talk Notes:
One of the many humorous things my teacher used to say is that the great thing about zazen is it's absolutely useless.
In other words we so obsessed with everything being useful, productive, and ideally optimized. And we also think we need a clear purpose and measurable outcomes for everything. There are for sure areas of life where this all makes perfect sense. But what happens to us when that become the only approach with any validity.
So it's good to engage in something that's not in that space. And sure we can also come up with some usefulness to zazen. It does help our lives otherwise why bother with it. But it just doesn't operate according to those kind of instrumental rules where measurement and analysis make sense. It's just crazy making at the end of a period of zazen to ask yourself, well how'd I do? Did I do a good job, am I getting better, am I waking up? This can just be a madhouse of self critical thinking. Don't do it. Zazen is zazen. Let zazen take care of itself, you don't need to be monitoring and tweaking and optimizing zazen.
Maybe it's helpful to reset your intentions from time to time or consider a shift in emphasis or technique once in a while, but only with a wide open and curious spirit. Maybe more out of a spirit of play than a spirit of improvement is best.
Something my teacher would add to that is, "well at least we weren't making any trouble while we were sitting here."
And that's actually a real thing. We tend to feel guilty for checking out of the busy life for 4 days, right, but does it occur to us that well maybe that's also giving all our relations a 4 day break from us. Not that they're all wiping their foreheads in relief as you walk out the door, I'm sure folks miss you, but there may also be all kinds of benefit to your non-presence too. Maybe someone stands up more on their own. Maybe someone feels more freedom to be themselves, and yeah it also means you aren't there with the opportunity to cause trouble through your own confusion.
Shantideva has some advice for us on how to stay out of trouble. This is in chapter 5 called "Guarding of Awareness"
5.48 - 5.54
5.47 When one wishes to move or to speak, first one should examine one's own mind, and then act appropriately and with self-possession.
5.48 When one notices one's own mind is attracted or repelled, one should neither act nor speak, but remain like a block of wood.
5.49 When the mind is inflated or derisive, full of arrogance and vanity, exceedingly jokey, evasive, or deceiving,
5.50 When, seeming to advance oneself, it is actually deprecating others, contemptuous and scornful, one should remain like a block of wood.
5.51 [When I see that] my mind seeks acquisitions, reverence, or renown, or wants and audience and attention, I should remain like a block of wood.
5.53 [If my mind is] intolerant, idle, cowardly, impudent, foul-mouthed, or biased in my own favor, I shall remain like a block of wood.
5.54 Noticing in this way that the mind is defiled or engaged in fruitless activity, the wise one should always firmly curb it with the antidote to that condition.
5.55 [I shall instead be] determined, full of serene confidence, steady, full of application and respect, with humility and timidity, calm, and eager to help others.
Very practical advice, no? Pay attention to your motivations and energy. When you're off, stop. Shut it. Take a breath. Be like a block of wood. Formal Zen training is very much in alignment with this approach.
And the usual caveats around how the other side is always included apply here. This doesn't mean to go into shut down and let yourself be abused. It's about responding wisely and thoughtfully when you're reactive. Waiting for yourself to settle down before you act. Cute eh? Be a block of wood.
And this isn't just about being a good person, it's about the larger project of cultivating bodhicitta - the orientation of the bodhisattva. The chapter is entitled "guarding of awareness" so the idea is that if you indulge in reactivity it's a bigger problem than being unhelpful in an interpersonal problem or being a jerk, it's that you've degraded bodhicitta and set yourself and everyone else back in our journey to awakening. And this, in Shantideva's, view is a much more serious issue than being a bit reactive.
A little later in the chapter he also gives some very straightforward positive advice about interpersonal relations. It's fun to remember that this is about 1,200 years old as it sounds very modern:
5.79 One should speak confident, measured words, clear in meaning, delighting in the mind, pleasing to the ear, soft and slow, and stemming from compassion.
5.80 One should always look at people directly, as if drinking them in with the eye: depending upon them alone, Buddha-hood will arise.
Sounds like something you'd hear in a Non Violent Communication workshop or something. But remembering his project is larger than good communication and getting along well, it's our mutual awakening as Buddha. But that all goes together very nicely.
We'll touch now into the chapter of the Bodhichāryāvatāra that's most often taught. Chapter 6 is the chapter on patience. If you run into Shantideva quotes they are often from this chapter. It turns out that to stay on the path of the bodhisattva patience is one of the most important things to cultivate and that we also need to broaden our view of what patience is.
What's meant here by patience isn't just tolerating something you don't like until it passes. It's a more engaged and accepting kind of practice. The Sanskrit is kshanti and it's sometimes translated as "forbearance" which is a synonym for tolerance. When kshanti is really humming it there is some cheerfulness in it. Sometimes we think of patience as a kind of grim endurance, this is something else.
The tradition suggestions there are three forms of patience. First is patience inspired by suffering. Second is patience inspired by the teachings. Third is patience inspired by injuries from others.
The enemy of patience is usually seen as anger so in Shantideva's extensive discussion of patience he has a lot to say about anger. About anger's cousin hatred.
This is very juicy stuff but we'll only have time to dip in briefly. I hope you'll consider continuing your study of Shantideva. Either on your own or I'm planning to do our Wednesday evening seminar at home on Shantideva next year - a dozen talks on Shantideva. We have a pretty good Zoom set up at our temple so you can join from here and I think you'll feel pretty engaged. And they'll all be recorded too.
Here's the opening of the chapter where Shantideva wants to really impress upon us how important the cultivation of patience is.
6.1 The worship of the Buddhas, generosity, and good conduct performed through thousands of aeons are very powerful, but anger destroys it all.
6.2 There is no evil equal to hatred, and no spiritual practice equal to patience. Therefore one should develop patience by many means and with great effort.
6.3 One's mind finds no peace, and neither enjoys pleasure or delight, nor can you sleep easily or feel secure while the dart of hatred and anger is stuck in the heart.
I'm mixing hatred and anger here a little for the underlying Sanskrit word is dveṣa which is the word usually translated as "hatred" when it shows up in the three core poisons of the mind: greed, hatred, and ignorance. But I think maybe if we hear "hatred" it can kind of bounce off of us: I don't hate anyone really. That might not be 1000% true but it's certainly how I tend to think about myself. But anger...? Yeah although I personally am good at suppressing anger there is no question that anger arises in the mind and heart.
Like reading about the huge pile up in the airports yesterday when radar communication systems apparently stopped talking to each other and all flights were grounded everywhere for 5 hours. The officials in charge started blaming their tools and even the past administration. A brief reading of the news showed no idea of any of those leaders taking responsibility or even apologizing to many thousands of people who had a terrible day yesterday - many are stuck stuck somewhere far from home trying to get home. If I'm honest, anger arose in my heart in response to that way of responding to a screw up. Anger along with resignation and a kind of vindictive "I told you so" energy.
According to Shantideva here I'd better watch it though. Fanning the fames of anger is enough to undo any positive results of my 40 years of Dharma practice in a flash:
6.1 The worship of the Buddhas, generosity, and good conduct performed through thousands of aeons are very powerful, but anger destroys it all.
So what do we do? Grin and bear it isn't quite right. Patience in this Buddhist sense includes both wisdom and compassion. We recognize deeply that conditioned beings are all kinds of ways and our wishing them to be another way than they are just causes suffering. Sometimes being mind-oriented people we go to a kind of cognitive reframing which is maybe a little relief. Like here, the people who get picked for cabinet posts like Sean Duffey as Secretary of Transportation in this administration seem to be selected for their skills at avoiding any appearance of responsibility for any problems ever as that might reflect back on their boss being imperfect. But that kind of thinking also leads us down all kinds of rabbit holes doesn't it?
So maybe thinking about something that's inspiring anger or impatience is a support for getting back to kshanti type patience but it's not the thing it self. Kshanti is a deep loving acceptance of the world as it is. It includes the wisdom that things break, people make mistakes, and stuff goes wrong.
Shantideva supports this aspect of our approach:
6.65 Even when people harm one's teachers, relatives, and others dear to us, one should regard it as arising on the basis of conditioning factors and refrain from anger towards them.
6.67 Some commit offences out of delusion. Others, deluded, grow angry. Who among them should we say is free from blme, or who should we say is guilty?
I don't know anything about Sean Duffey's particular story of conditioning but I know he's a human being in a culture, and a sub culture, who's been trained to react to things in certain ways. He does still have choice and intelligence but we recognize the power of conditioning and feel a little sympathy.
And kshanti patience includes the wisdom that a lot of our suffering is based on the expectation of how things are supposed to go and we get upset when our attempts to control the future are stymied. That we're carrying around in us the fertile seeds of impatience that we unknowingly create good conditions for all the time with our expectations and assumptions. I have a relevant airport story for this actually.
[story of getting to Norman's in October, including how I did practice asserting myself with the rebooking agent]
But here as he tends to Shantideva encourages us to go even deeper. Not to see the Sean Duffey's of the world as merely opportunities to release our anger and be bigger, kinder people but to see them as our wondrous teachers. This was a hard sell even himself and for his monastic contemporaries I guess we work our way into this idea.
First he reminds us of why we got into this bodhisattva business in the first place:
6.80 After arousing the Awakening Mind out of desire for the happiness of all beings, why are you angry at them now?
Next he reminds us that we aren't blameless either - this part gets quite intricate but here's an impression of it:
6.86 [modified] You too must grieve at the evil you have done. And you can even be scornful of others who perform good works.
6.87 [modified] Suppose something unpleasant befalls your rival. Do you indulge in satisfaction?
6.88 [modified] If so, would there really be true pleasure for you in another's suffering?
And he digs in around any desire we may have to look good in all of this, too! In this second he switches back and forth between first and second person in an intricate way too - it's like he's having an argument with himself.
6.93 I'm like a child who howls a wail of distress when my sandcastle is broken - so my mind appears to me at the loss of praise or renown.
6.97 [Even when I am praised] the delight that is produced in my is absurd - simply the behavior of a child.
And he urges to watch out for giving ourselves false comfort - another way of being a victim of comfort:
6.98 Praise gives me security. And that destroys my sense of urgency. It can even create jealousy towards those who possess true virtue and anger at their success.
And then we have the really challenging coaching from Shantideva on this deep wise patience:
107 Since enemies help me on the path to Awakening, I shall long for an enemy like a treasure discovered in my own home acquired without effort.
108 [In the end,] both my enemy and myself will receive the reward of patience. It should be given to my enemy first, since the patience was occasioned by him.
110 If an enemy is not honored because their intention is to hurt, for what other reason will I be patient with them, as with a doctor who is intent on my well-being.
In other words don't waste the extremely fortunate practice opportunity of having someone be mean to you. Few other situations are more powerful for developing deep patience. Treat that person like a doctor giving you bitter medicine offered with nothing but the wish for your well being.
And finally, for now:
111 It is trully on dependent upon their malign intention that true patience is produced. It is really the enemy that is the cause of patience. I must worship my enemy as the True Dharma.